The Theory Post That Started it All…

Written by robotical712.

This was my first full theory regarding how Rey ended up on Jakku and what my full background theory evolved from. I posted this on the Star Wars Speculation subreddit on April 25, 2016:

I’m at a point where I feel confident that I’ve largely figured out what Rey’s intended backstory is. I believe the only real coincidences are the Falcon(1) and BB-8 rolling directly into Rey (although this is almost certainly Force directed).

After RotJ, Luke spent some time searching for Jedi related artifacts and information. During his travels he fell in love and got married, resulting in a child (Rey). His wife assisted him in his research. At some point, Luke started looking for the First Jedi Temple, before he even set up the academy (temple, whatever). When Rey was about five, Luke or Rey’s mother came across information that a map to the temple was on a crashed Imperial vessel on Jakku, and her mother (or whomever) went to investigate and brought Rey along. The obvious first step in locating the map was contacting the local salvage dealer, Unkar Plutt (since most of the recovered salvage went through him).

In all likelihood, Snoke learned of their intended trip and planned an ambush for them(2, 3). As the five year old granddaughter of the chosen one, Snoke’s objective would most likely have been to kidnap and turn her to the darkside (with the added bonus of hurting Luke). Somehow, Rey’s mother had a premonition or received warning of the impending attack, but only had enough time for one course of action. There was no time to hide or find help and her guardian left Rey with Unkar and flew off to draw their attackers from Rey. Alas, she was killed or sacrificed herself before she could call for help. This event turned out particularly tragic for young Force-Sensitive Rey; she felt her mother die.

There has been a lot of discussion about what Rey remembers and she states she doesn’t know where she came from or how she ended up on Jakku in one of the books. Some have theorized a mindwipe, but I think there is good evidence for another explanation – she does remember and is doing her damnedest not to. Feeling her mother’s death would have been horrific for five year old Rey and her reaction was to consciously suppress her own connection to the Force(4). To her father, Luke, and anyone else attuned to her, it would appear she died with her mother. Knowing her mother was dead and how she knew that was far too painful for Rey and she created and clung to a far more comforting fiction – her ‘family’ (which was a comforting abstraction) had accidentally left her behind and were coming back for her. This is why she was so anxious about leaving Jakku, because it risked forcing her to acknowledge what she already knew.

Her deepest fears came true when Rey had the Forceback and Maz told Rey she already knew the truth. These events punctured the belief that had kept her going, but also in a prison of her own making all these years. Understandably, this was a massive emotional blow to Rey and she instinctively rejected it and fled (the book even mentions she was running from herself). By the end of TFA she has accepted that she has been clinging to a fantasy, but I believe she has yet to really acknowledge she already knows what happened and who she is.

Notes:
Years later, LST either learned of the map or followed the lead that brought Rey’s mother to the planet and eventually succeeded in finding it (he had no idea she was there and may have never met her).
1) I don’t think the Falcon has anything to do with Rey’s backstory. Abrams simply wanted it to be the ship Rey and Finn escape on.
2) Snoke may have learned of Rey’s mother’s plans through an unwitting Ben.
3) Jakku was unaligned and could be directly accessed from the unknown regions, making it the perfect location for an ambush.
4) That she was consciously suppressing her connection to the Force is further supported by the fact her visions of the island came when she was on the verge of sleep.
Edit: I don’t think Snoke knew the map was on Jakku until LST found it.
Edit 2: Plutt has no idea who she is and was not involved with the attackers. From his perspective, her mother suddenly panicked, left Rey there and never came back.


Like this? Follow us on FacebookTwitter, Tumblr or here on WordPress!

Join our Discord: https://discord.gg/HVKN3dT

Advertisements

3 comments

  1. I like this theory but have to ask: what mother would drag along a 5 yr. old on jedi business to a place like Jakku? I realize this goes against what we saw in Rey’s force vision, but wouldn’t it make more sense if Rey was actually 13-16 yrs. old, making her a young padawan accompanying her mother, who was possibly also a jedi. This appeals to me because Rey was already trained when we meet her in TFA; it makes sense if Rey already instinctively knew how to call a weapon to her hand, how to use a lightsaber before the duel in the snowy woods with Kylo, how to do the jedi mind trick, and how to resist a mind probe.

    I like the idea that Rey was severely traumatized, so much so that she had amnesia or repressed memories, unable to recall her parents, her last name, how she was on Jakku and that she had to wait for them to return. Might her state of mind have caused her to twist events, such as her being a little girl in her force vision? Might this twist of events and her amnesia have given Kylo this picture during the mind rape from a certain point of view (Rey’s), then reflected back to her after the throne room fight, that her parents were nobodies because her mind had locked that memory away. This, Ruin said, was Kylo telling “the truth from a certain point of view.”

    Just now it also occurred to me that what if… Rey might have saved her mother or at least gone to her defense, but was frozen in fear or obeyed her mother’s order to hide, stay and wait for her return, and instead watched her die before her eyes. Would this also be a fear or guilt or shame enough to cause amnesia or repressed memories, or to twist reality — being too young (in the force vision), blameless and helpless would make this easier to bear. Rey’s reaction to this part of the force vision is one of horror.

    Also I get the impression that both JJ and Ruin deliberately withheld or misled us about not only Rey’s origin but Finn’s as well.

    The whole ST is about Rey’s allowing herself to remember, to break through the cracks in her repressed memories about herself and the family she belongs to, somehow.

    Liked by 1 person

    • This was my first theory and it’s evolved considerably over the last few years. I’m currently doing a full update of my background theory and will be writing out my theory for what happened to Rey and her mother in the course of it. Stay tuned!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s